Our Menu
We’ve Made Some Changes to our Menu, Check Out What’s New!
Doing what we do Best
We’ve been serving New York style pizza in Colorado since 1984, and one thing has never changed, people come to Anthony’s for our legendary pizza and a straight-up solid meal.
Our new menu is all about doubling down on what we do best. We listened to what our guests love, added a few new items, and trimmed some of our less popular items.
We also unified prices across every Anthony’s restaurant to make ordering clearer, more consistent, and an even better value for every guest who walks through our doors.
Xtra Large Pizzas
Our massive 22″ pizza has been a dine-in favorite for years, but now it’s available to order as the biggest item on our menu! We’ve simplified our sizes to Medium (14″), Large (18″), and our Xtra Large (22″), so there’s no room for debating when it comes to feeding a hungry crowd.
Whether you’re sharing a whole pizza or just want the real New York slice experience, the 22″ house pie is now just a click away.
Baked Pastas
We’ve retired some pastas from the menu and doubled down on what our guests love, baked, cheesy and crave-worthy pasta. Our Classic Baked Ziti now sits alongside two new favorites:
Pesto Baked Ziti with vibrant pesto and roasted grape tomatoes
Sausage Baked Ziti with Italian sausage, sautéed onions, Alfredo, and our signature white sauce
Every Baked Ziti Pasta on our menu is oven baked, extra cheesy, and packed with flavor all the way to the last bite.
Thick Crust Style
We’ve added a brand-new thick crust pizza to the menu. It starts with our original dough and sauce recipes, gets loaded with mozzarella, and bakes up into four thick and hearty slices. It’s airy on the inside, crispy on the outside, and stacked with cheese and sauce.
Slices & More Since '84
Great food shouldn’t break the bank. That is why we doubled down on bringing more of what our guests love to the menu while keeping the value you have known for decades.
There is nothing fancy about what we do, and that is exactly the point. Just honest New York style pizza made from scratch every day. Fresh sauce, hand tossed dough, stone baked pizzas.
Grab a slice, share a pie, and make some memories.
Order Online
Skip the wait and enjoy fresh, hot NY-style pizza. Order with ease and savor every bite!